"Well," he said, dropping his work and looking up to impress me, "I"m a man that"ll sometimes say what I don"t believe; that is, I"ll agree with what I hadn"t ought to, just to be friendly like. I did that way a lot o" times with Elihu till one day he came to me with something about particular salvation. I"m a little more liberal myself. I believe in universal redemption by faith alone. Well, Elihu came to me and began telling me what he believed. Finally he asked me something about particular salvation and wanted to know whether I didn"t agree with him.

I didn"t, and told him so. From that day on he took a set against me, and he ain"t never spoke a word to me since."

I was unaware that there was anything besides a religious disagreement in this local situation until one day I happened to come into a second friendly contact with the postmaster. We were speaking of the characteristics of certain individuals, and I mentioned Burridge.

"He"s all right when you take him the way he wants to be taken. When you don"t you"ll find him quite a different man."

"He seems to be straightforward and honest," I said.

"There ain"t anything you can tell me about Elihu Burridge that I don"t know," he replied feelingly. "Not a thing. I"ve lived with him, as you might say, all my life. Been raised right here in town with him, and we went to school together. Man and boy, there ain"t ever been a thing that Elihu has agreed with, without he could have the running of it. You can"t tell me anything about him that I don"t know."

I could not help smiling at the warmth of feeling, although something about the man"s manner bespoke a touch of heart-ache, as if he were privately grieving.

"What was the trouble between you two?" I asked.

"It"s more"n I could ever find out," he replied in a voice that was really mournful, so difficult and non-understandable was the subject to him. "Before I started to work for this office there wasn"t a day that I didn"t meet and speak friendly with Elihu. He used to have a good many deeds and papers to sign, and he never failed to call me in when I was pa.s.sing. When I started to work for this office I noticed he took on a cold manner toward me, and I tried to think of something I might have done, but I couldn"t. Finally I wrote and asked him if there was anything between us if he wouldn"t set a time and place so"s we might talk it over and come to an understanding." He paused and then added, "I wish you could see the letter he wrote me. Comin" from a Christian man--from him to me--I wish you could see it."

"Why don"t you show it to me?" I asked inquisitively.

He went back into the office and returned with an ancient-looking doc.u.ment, four years old it proved to be, which he had been treasuring.

He handed me the thumbed and already yellowed page, and I read:

"MATTHEW HOLCOMB, ESQUIRE,

"DEAR SIR:--In reply to your letter asking me to set a time and place in which we might talk over the trouble between us, would say that the time be Eternity and the place where G.o.d shall call us to judgment.

"Very truly, "ELIHU BURRIDGE."

His eyes rested on me while I read, and the moment I finished he began with:

"I never said one word against that man, not one word. I never did a thing he could take offense at, not one thing. I don"t know how a man can justify himself writing like that."

"Perhaps it"s political," I said. "You don"t belong to the same party, do you?"

"Yes, we do," he said. "Sometimes I"ve thought that maybe it was because I had the support of the shipyard when I first tried to get this office, but then that wasn"t anything between him and me," and he looked away as if the mystery were inexplicable.

This shipyard was conducted by a most forceful man but one as narrow and religionistic as this region in which it had had its rise. Old Mr.

Palmer, the aged founder of it, had long been a notable figure in the streets and private chambers of the village. The princ.i.p.al grocery store, coal-yard, sail-loft, hotel and other inst.i.tutions were conducted in its interests. His opinion was always foremost in the decision of the local authorities. He was still, reticent, un.o.btrusive. Once I saw him most considerately helping a cripple up the lane to the local Baptist Church.

"What"s the trouble between Burridge and Palmer?" I asked of the sail-maker finally, coming to think that here, if anywhere, lay the solution of the difficulty.

"Two big fish in too small a basket," he responded laconically.

"Can"t agree, eh?"

"They both want to lead, or did," he said. "Elihu"s a beaten man, though, now." He paused and then added, "I"m sorry for Elihu. He"s a good man at heart, one of the kindest men you ever saw, when you let him follow his natural way. He"s good to the poor, and he"s carried more slow-pay people than any man in this country, I do believe. He won"t collect an old debt by law. Don"t believe in it. No, sir. Just a kind-hearted man, but he loves to rule."

"How about Palmer?" I inquired.

"Just the same way exactly. He loves to rule, too. Got a good heart, too, but he"s got a lot more money than Elihu and so people pay more attention to him, that"s all. When Elihu was getting the attention he was just the finest man you ever saw, kind, generous, good-natured.

People love to be petted, at least some people do--you know they do.

When you don"t pet "em they get kind o" sour and crabbed like. Now that"s all that"s the matter with Elihu, every bit of it. He"s sour, now, and a little lonely, I expect. He"s drove away every one from him, or nearly all, "cept his wife and some of his kin. Anybody can do a good grocery business here, with the strangers off the boats"--the harbor was a lively one--"all you have to do is carry a good stock. That"s why he gets along so well. But he"s drove nearly all the local folks away from him."

I listened to this comfortable sail-loft sage, and going back to the grocery store one afternoon took another look at the long, grim-faced silent figure. He was sitting in the shadow of one of his moldy corners, and if there had ever been any light of merriment in his face it was not there now. He looked as fixed and solemn as an ancient puritan, and yet there was something so melancholy in the man"s eye, so sad and disappointed, that it seemed anything but hard. Two or three little children were playing about the door and when he came forward to wait on me one of them sidled forward and put her chubby hand in his.

"Your children?" I asked, by way of reaching some friendly understanding.

"No," he replied, looking fondly down, "she belongs to a French lady up the street here. She often comes down to see me, don"t you?" and he reached over and took the fat little cheek between his thumb and forefinger.

The little one rubbed her face against his worn baggy trousers" leg and put her arm about his knee. Quietly he stood there in a simple way until she loosened her hold upon him, when he went about his labor.

I was sitting one day in the loft of the comfortable sail-maker, who, by the way, was brother-in-law to Burridge, when I said to him:

"I wish you"d tell me the details about Elihu. How did he come to be what he is? You ought to know; you"ve lived here all your life."

"So I do know," he replied genially. "What do you want me to tell you?"

"The whole story of the trouble between him and Palmer; how he comes to be at outs with all these people."

"Well," he began, and here followed with many interruptions and side elucidations, which for want of s.p.a.ce have been eliminated, the following details:

Twenty-five years before Elihu had been the leading citizen of Noank.

From operating a small grocery at the close of the Civil War he branched out until he sold everything from ship-rigging to hardware. Noank was then in the height of its career as a fishing town and as a port from which expeditions of all sorts were wont to sail. Whaling was still in force, and vessels for whaling expeditions were equipped here. Wealthy sea-captains frequently loaded fine three-masted schooners here for various trading expeditions to all parts of the world; the fishers for mackerel, cod and herring were making three hundred and fifty dollars a day in season, and thousands of dollars" worth of supplies were annually purchased here.

Burridge was then the only tradesman of any importance and, being of a liberal, strong-minded and yet religious turn, attracted the majority of this business to him. He had houses and lands, was a deacon in the local Baptist Church and a counselor in matters political, social and religious, whose advice was seldom rejected. Every Fourth of July during these years it was his custom to collect all the children of the town in front of his store and treat them to ice-cream. Every Christmas Eve he traveled about the streets in a wagon, which carried half a dozen barrels of candy and nuts, which he would ladle out to the merry shouting throng of pursuing youngsters, until all were satisfied. For the skating season he prepared a pond, spending several thousand dollars damming up a small stream, in order that the children might have a place to skate. He created a library where all might obtain suitable reading, particularly the young.

On New Year"s morning it was his custom to visit all the poor and bereaved and lonely in Noank, taking a great dray full of presents and leaving a little something with his greetings and a pleasant handshake at every door. The lonely rich as well as the lonely poor were included, for he was certain, as he frequently declared, that the rich could be lonely too.

He once told his brother-in-law that one New Year"s Day a voice called to him in church: "Elihu Burridge, how about the lonely rich and poor of Noank?" "Up I got," he concluded, "and from that day to this I have never neglected them."

When any one died who had a little estate to be looked after for the benefit of widows or orphans, Burridge was the one to take charge of it.

People on their deathbeds sent for him, and he always responded, taking energetic charge of everything and refusing to take a penny for his services. After a number of years the old judge to whom he always repaired with these matters of probate, knowing his generosity in this respect, also refused to accept any fee. When he saw him coming he would exclaim:

"Well, Elihu, what is it this time? Another widow or orphan that we"ve got to look after?"

After Elihu had explained what it was, he would add:

"Well, Elihu, I do hope that some day some rich man will call you to straighten out his affairs. I"d like to see _you_ get a little something, so that _I_ might get a little something. Eh, Elihu?" Then he would jocularly poke his companion in charity in the ribs.

These general benefactions were continuous and coeval with his local prosperity and dominance, and their modification as well as the man"s general decline the result of the rise of this other individual--Robert Palmer,--"operating" to take the color of power and preeminence from him.

Palmer was the owner of a small shipyard here at the time, a thing which was not much at first but which grew swiftly. He was born in Noank also, a few years before Burridge, and as a builder of vessels had been slowly forging his way to a moderate competence when Elihu was already successful. He was a keen, fine-featured, energetic individual, with excellent commercial and strong religious instincts, and by dint of hard labor and a saving disposition he obtained, soon after the Civil War, a powerful foothold. Many vessels were ordered here from other cities.

Eventually he began to build barges in large numbers for a great railroad company.

Early becoming a larger employer of labor than any one else in the vicinity he soon began to branch out, possessed himself of the allied industries of ship-rigging, chandlering, and finally established a grocery store for his employees, and opened a hotel. Now the local citizens began to look upon him as their leading citizen. They were always talking of his rise, frequently in the presence of Burridge. He said nothing at first, pretending to believe that his quondam leadership was unimpaired. Again, there were those who, having followed the various branches of labor which Palmer eventually consolidated, viewed this growth with sullen and angry eyes. They still sided with Burridge, or pretended still to believe that he was the more important citizen of the two. In the course of time, however--a period of thirty years or more--some of them failed; others died; still others were driven away for want of a livelihood. Only Burridge"s position and business remained, but in a sadly weakened state. He was no longer a man of any great importance.

Not unnaturally, this question of local supremacy was first tested in the one place in which local supremacy is usually tested--the church where they both worshiped. Although only one of five trustees, Burridge had been the will of the body. Always, whatever he thought, the others had almost immediately agreed to it. But now that Palmer had become a power, many of those ardent in the church and beholden to him for profit became his humble followers. They elected him trustee and did what he wished, or what they thought he wished. To Burridge this made them sycophants, slaves.

Now followed the kind of trivialities by which most human feuds are furthered. The first test of strength came when a vagrant evangelist from Alabama arrived and desired to use the church for a series of evening lectures. The question had to be decided at once. Palmer was absent at the time.